All insights

Evaluation as a source of learning

Evaluations are often commissioned because a grant agreement requires them. The terms of reference are copied from the last one, the report arrives as the project closes, and its recommendations are filed. The organisation has paid for knowledge it never uses. It does not have to be this way.

Ask questions someone needs answered

The value of an evaluation depends on its questions. Before writing terms of reference, ask the managers, partners and, where possible, community representatives what they need to know. Questions linked to real decisions, such as whether to scale up, change the approach or continue in a location, produce findings that get used.

Use the standard criteria with judgement

Relevance, coherence, effectiveness, efficiency, impact and sustainability give a useful structure, but not every evaluation needs to cover all six in equal depth. Choose the criteria and methods that fit the question, the population and the operating context, and be clear about the limits of what the evidence can show.

  • Time the evaluation so findings arrive before the next decision.
  • Include the perspectives of affected people, not only staff and documents.
  • Separate what was observed from claims about cause and effect.
  • Agree a management response: who will act on each recommendation, and by when.

Independence and learning are compatible

An independent evaluator brings distance and credibility. Close engagement with the team does not threaten that independence; it makes the findings more accurate and more likely to be accepted. The goal is an honest account of what worked, what did not, and why, delivered in a way that people can act on.

When evaluation is treated as a learning tool, it does more than satisfy a donor. It helps organisations understand their results, demonstrate accountability and make better choices for the people they serve.